Fairly rated · Updated October 2026
Melbourne insurance brokers, fairly rated
As of October 2026, the three most fairly rated insurance brokers in Melbourne, VIC on Good Repute are ProTrades Insurance (5.0 from 51 Google reviews), Tony Insurance (5.0 from 49 Google reviews) and McKenzie Ross Business Insurance Brokers (4.9 from 109 Google reviews).
- Insurance Brokers compared
- 56
- Google reviews
- 3,130
- Median rating
- 4.9
| # | Business | Rating | Google reviews | Contact |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ProTrades Insurance | 51 Google reviews | ||
| 2 | Tony Insurance101 Collins St, Melbourne VIC 3000 | 49 Google reviews | ||
| 3 | McKenzie Ross Business Insurance Brokers501 La Trobe St, Melbourne VIC 3000 | 109 Google reviews | ||
| 4 | Astute Financial Melbourne City SouthLevel 1, Suite 1, 480 Saint Kilda Road, Melbourne VIC 3004 | 91 Google reviews | ||
| 5 | Global Insurance SolutionsLevel 3, Building 7, Botanicca Corporate Park, 570/588 Swan St | 24 Google reviews | ||
| 6 | Fundamental Insurance Brokers Melbourne230 Collins St, Melbourne VIC 3000 | 58 Google reviews | ||
| 7 | Capital Means | 19 Google reviews | ||
| 8 | Martial Arts Australia Insurance Services | 15 Google reviews | ||
| 9 | Bluewell Insurance Brokers | 500 Google reviews | ||
| 10 | Moran Insurance Brokers149-151 Cremorne St, Melbourne VIC 3121 | 8 Google reviews | ||
| 11 | Axle Insurance BrokersBotannica Corporate Park, Level 3, Building 7/570-588 Swan St | 7 Google reviews | ||
| 12 | Grace Insurance Victoria (Melbourne) | 17 Google reviews | ||
| 13 | Arca Insurance Brokers | 6 Google reviews | ||
| 14 | KBI Group Pty Ltd | 6 Google reviews | ||
| 15 | Midland Insurance Brokers | 69 Google reviews | ||
| 16 | Australian Insurance Services Alliance (AISA) | 5 Google reviews | ||
| 17 | Benjamin & Benjamin Insurance Group198 Harbour Espl, Melbourne VIC 3008 | 5 Google reviews | ||
| 18 | M & M Insurance Services Pty Ltd | 5 Google reviews | ||
| 19 | My Insurance Broker | 5 Google reviews | ||
| 20 | Three Peaks Insurance | 5 Google reviews | ||
| 21 | onefocusLevel 24, 530 Collins Street, Melbourne VIC 3000 | 7 Google reviews | ||
| 22 | BJS Insurance Brokers | 10 Google reviews | ||
| 23 | EBM Insurance & Risk - MelbourneBldg 8, Level 2/584 Swan St | 28 Google reviews | ||
| 24 | Professional Integrity Pty Ltd | 4 Google reviews | ||
| 25 | Heron Insurance Group585 Little Collins St #478, Melbourne VIC 3000 | 3 Google reviews | ||
| 26 | LJM Insurance | 3 Google reviews | ||
| 27 | Lifebroker390 La Trobe St, Melbourne VIC 3000 | 66 Google reviews | ||
| 28 | GJ Insurance Consulting Pty Ltd | 4 Google reviews | ||
| 29 | ADK Insurance Brokers233 Cardigan St, Melbourne VIC 3053 | 2 Google reviews | ||
| 30 | Australia Underwriting | 2 Google reviews | ||
| 31 | Insurance Advisernet - Pace Insurance | 2 Google reviews | ||
| 32 | PSC Insurance Brokers (Melbourne) | 10 Google reviews | ||
| 33 | ACUITY RISK SOLUTIONS | 1 Google review | ||
| 34 | AIC Insurance Brokers | 1 Google review | ||
| 35 | Assured Insurance Brokers63 Exhibition St #8, Melbourne VIC 3000 | 1 Google review | ||
| 36 | Interpacific Insurance Brokers15 Hancock St, Melbourne VIC 3006 | 1 Google review | ||
| 37 | Mason Wells Insurance Brokers | 1 Google review | ||
| 38 | Pioneer Insurance Group | 1 Google review | ||
| 39 | Solution Underwriting Agency | 1 Google review | ||
| 40 | Yes Insurance Group222 Kings Way, Melbourne VIC 3205 | 162 Google reviews | ||
| 41 | PSC Alliance Insurance Brokers | 4 Google reviews | ||
| 42 | DGA Insurance Brokers256 Queen St, Melbourne VIC 3000 | 15 Google reviews | ||
| 43 | Ascot Insurance Group | 6 Google reviews | ||
| 44 | Swann Insurance181 William Street, Melbourne VIC 3000 | 634 Google reviews | ||
| 45 | Network Insurance House | 12 Google reviews | ||
| 46 | One Underwriting | 1 Google review | ||
| 47 | 1300 Insurance101 Collins St, Melbourne VIC 3000 | 7 Google reviews | ||
| 48 | Lockton Companies Australia Pty Ltd - Melbourne | 2 Google reviews | ||
| 49 | ATIA Insurance Services | 5 Google reviews | ||
| 50 | Aon Melbourne | 13 Google reviews |
Good Repute compared 56 insurance brokers in Melbourne, VIC, with 3,130 Google reviews between them. Of these, 56 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.9 from a median of 7 reviews.
Of the insurance brokers compared, the most reviewed is iSelect, with 693 Google reviews at 4.0.
How this list is ranked
Businesses are ranked by their Google rating, pulled toward 4.5 as if each had 10 more reviews at 4.5, so five stars from four reviews does not beat 4.9 from four hundred. Ties go to the business with more reviews.
It does not measure price, speed or the quality of any one job, and it knows only the reviews people left on Google.
Questions
- Which insurance brokers in Melbourne, VIC are the most fairly rated?
- As of October 2026, the three most fairly rated insurance brokers in Melbourne, VIC on Good Repute are ProTrades Insurance (5.0 from 51 Google reviews), Tony Insurance (5.0 from 49 Google reviews) and McKenzie Ross Business Insurance Brokers (4.9 from 109 Google reviews).
- How does Good Repute rank insurance brokers in Melbourne, VIC?
- Businesses are ranked by their Google rating, pulled toward 4.5 as if each had 10 more reviews at 4.5, so five stars from four reviews does not beat 4.9 from four hundred. Ties go to the business with more reviews. It does not measure price, speed or the quality of any one job, and it knows only the reviews people left on Google.
- How many insurance brokers in Melbourne, VIC did Good Repute compare?
- Good Repute compared 56 insurance brokers in Melbourne, VIC, with 3,130 Google reviews between them. Of these, 56 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.9 from a median of 7 reviews.
- Can a business pay to be listed or to rank higher?
- No. Every business is ranked by the same published method, and no business can pay to be listed or to move up.