Fairly rated · Updated October 2026
South Australian insurance brokers, fairly rated
As of October 2026, the three most fairly rated insurance brokers in South Australia on Good Repute are Elders Insurance Whyalla (5.0 from 36 Google reviews), Be Covered Insurance Brokers Adelaide (5.0 from 32 Google reviews) and Elders Insurance Adelaide West (5.0 from 32 Google reviews).
- Insurance Brokers compared
- 84
- Google reviews
- 962
- Median rating
- 4.6
| # | Business | Rating | Google reviews | Contact |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Elders Insurance Whyalla2 Patterson St, Whyalla SA 5600 | 36 Google reviews | ||
| 2 | Be Covered Insurance Brokers Adelaide | 32 Google reviews | ||
| 3 | Elders Insurance Adelaide West | 32 Google reviews | ||
| 4 | Capstone Insurance Brokersby Appointment only, 167 Flinders St | 26 Google reviews | ||
| 5 | Flinders Insurance Solutions1-3 Metro Pde, Adelaide SA 5095 | 26 Google reviews | ||
| 6 | Insurance Advisernet - Acorn Insurance Services | 17 Google reviews | ||
| 7 | Elders Insurance Mawson Lakes | 33 Google reviews | ||
| 8 | Wealth On Track213 Greenhill Rd, Adelaide SA 5063 | 14 Google reviews | ||
| 9 | Online Business Insurance Brokers119 Findon Road, Findon SA 5023 | 13 Google reviews | ||
| 10 | Maxton Insurance Brokers22 Fullarton Rd, Adelaide SA 5067 | 10 Google reviews | ||
| 11 | Thomas Insurance Brokers48 King William Road, Unit 2, Goodwood SA 5034 | 10 Google reviews | ||
| 12 | Gavin Goedecke - Insurance Broker | 9 Google reviews | ||
| 13 | Australian Pacific Business Insurance (APBI) | 7 Google reviews | ||
| 14 | Bonython Risk Management | 7 Google reviews | ||
| 15 | KWI66-70 Murray St, Nuriootpa SA 5355 | 10 Google reviews | ||
| 16 | DeConno & Blanco Insurance Brokers | 6 Google reviews | ||
| 17 | Eastern Equity Insurance Brokers | 5 Google reviews | ||
| 18 | Fundamental Insurance Brokers Adelaide217 Flinders St, Adelaide SA 5000 | 5 Google reviews | ||
| 19 | Lion Insurance ServicesSuite 220, Level 2/33 Pirie St | 5 Google reviews | ||
| 20 | ONE Insurance Group50 Hindmarsh Sq, Adelaide SA 5000 | 12 Google reviews | ||
| 21 | TLM Insurance Solutions | 12 Google reviews | ||
| 22 | Bfrank Insurance56 Sydenham Road, Norwood SA 5067 | 4 Google reviews | ||
| 23 | Cowden (SA) Pty LtdLevel 1/102 Greenhill Rd | 4 Google reviews | ||
| 24 | GIA Insurance Brokers - Murray Bridge (formerly Managed Insurance Solutions)253 Adelaide Rd, Murray Bridge SA 5253 | 4 Google reviews | ||
| 25 | Hancock Insurance Agencies178 Main Rd, McLaren Vale SA 5171 | 4 Google reviews | ||
| 26 | Murdoch Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd127 Swanport Rd, Murray Bridge SA 5253 | 4 Google reviews | ||
| 27 | Elders Insurance Southern Vales164 Main Rd, McLaren Vale SA 5171 | 4 Google reviews | ||
| 28 | Brian Cotter Insurance Agencies48 Patterson St, Whyalla SA 5600 | 2 Google reviews | ||
| 29 | Business Insurance Services Pty Ltd | 2 Google reviews | ||
| 30 | Dynamic Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd | 2 Google reviews | ||
| 31 | My Insurance House | 2 Google reviews | ||
| 32 | Safeguard Insurance Brokers285 Anzac Hwy, Adelaide SA 5038 | 2 Google reviews | ||
| 33 | Money Merchants Financial Services91 South Rd, Adelaide SA 5031 | 21 Google reviews | ||
| 34 | SUREWiSE | Insurance Brokers Adelaide | 18 Google reviews | ||
| 35 | City Rural Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd.200 Greenhill Rd, Adelaide SA 5063 | 10 Google reviews | ||
| 36 | Ausure City & Rural49 Murray St, Tanunda SA 5352 | 1 Google review | ||
| 37 | GIA Insurance Brokers - Adelaide198 Greenhill Rd, Adelaide SA 5063 | 1 Google review | ||
| 38 | GIA Insurance Brokers - Aldinga (formerly Managed Insurance Solutions) | 1 Google review | ||
| 39 | INSURE TODAYSuite 312, Lvl 3/147 Pirie St | 1 Google review | ||
| 40 | KeyInsure | 1 Google review | ||
| 41 | M2M Risk & Insurance Pty Ltd17 O'Brien St, Adelaide SA 5000 | 1 Google review | ||
| 42 | Protectit Insurance Services | 1 Google review | ||
| 43 | Securitex Insurance Services | 1 Google review | ||
| 44 | Thompson Insurance Services13 Flinders Terrace, Port Augusta SA 5700 | 1 Google review | ||
| 45 | GIA Insurance Brokers - Goolwa (formerly The Insurance Office)7B Loveday St, Goolwa SA 5214 | 8 Google reviews | ||
| 46 | iinsure57 Henley Beach Rd, Adelaide SA 5031 | 5 Google reviews | ||
| 47 | Elders Insurance Glenelg | 4 Google reviews | ||
| 48 | Australian Commercial & Transport Insurance | 1 Google review | ||
| 49 | Elders Insurance Victor Harbor11-13 Victoria St, Victor Harbor SA 5211 | 3 Google reviews | ||
| 50 | Elders Insurance ModburyVia, 12 Valiant Road Access, Rear 732 North East Road | 9 Google reviews |
Good Repute compared 84 insurance brokers in South Australia, with 962 Google reviews between them. Of these, 84 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.6 from a median of 5 reviews.
Of the insurance brokers compared, the most reviewed is EML, with 81 Google reviews at 1.9.
How this list is ranked
Businesses are ranked by their Google rating, pulled toward 4.5 as if each had 10 more reviews at 4.5, so five stars from four reviews does not beat 4.9 from four hundred. Ties go to the business with more reviews.
It does not measure price, speed or the quality of any one job, and it knows only the reviews people left on Google.
Questions
- Which insurance brokers in South Australia are the most fairly rated?
- As of October 2026, the three most fairly rated insurance brokers in South Australia on Good Repute are Elders Insurance Whyalla (5.0 from 36 Google reviews), Be Covered Insurance Brokers Adelaide (5.0 from 32 Google reviews) and Elders Insurance Adelaide West (5.0 from 32 Google reviews).
- How does Good Repute rank insurance brokers in South Australia?
- Businesses are ranked by their Google rating, pulled toward 4.5 as if each had 10 more reviews at 4.5, so five stars from four reviews does not beat 4.9 from four hundred. Ties go to the business with more reviews. It does not measure price, speed or the quality of any one job, and it knows only the reviews people left on Google.
- How many insurance brokers in South Australia did Good Repute compare?
- Good Repute compared 84 insurance brokers in South Australia, with 962 Google reviews between them. Of these, 84 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.6 from a median of 5 reviews.
- Can a business pay to be listed or to rank higher?
- No. Every business is ranked by the same published method, and no business can pay to be listed or to move up.